Frameset - question

Predicate: question

Roleset id: question.01 , ask a question (of a listener), Source: , vncls: , framnet:

question.01: QUESTION-V NOTES: Former file, question-v.01, based on sentences in financial subcorpus. The former file encompassed allverb senses. Member of VNcls interrogate-37.1.3. (from question.01-v) QUESTION-N NOTES: Former file, question-n.01, based on question-v.01. Framed by Katie. (from question.01-n) QUESTIONING-N NOTES: question.01 (from questioning.01-n)

Aliases:

Alias	FrameNet	VerbNet
question (n.)	Questioning Point_of_dispute
question (v.)	Questioning
questioning (n.)	Questioning
have_question (l.)

Roles:

        Arg0-PAG: asker (vnrole: 37.1.3-agent)
        Arg1-PPT: question (vnrole: 37.1.3-topic)
        Arg2-GOL: entity asked, hearer (vnrole: 37.1.3-recipient)

Example: ARG0 and ARG2 and ARG1

        Then Peter was filled with the Holy Spirit and said to them , `` Rulers of the people and you older leaders , are you questioning us today about what we did to help this crippled man ?

        Argm-dis: Rulers of the people and you older leaders
        Arg0: you
        Rel: questioning
        Arg2: us
        Argm-tmp: today
        Arg1: about what we did
        Argm-prp: to help this crippled man

Example: question-n: Example with arg 2

        I have a question for Mr. Laband

        Rel: question
        Arg2: for Mr. Laband

Example: question-n: arg 0 and 1

        an attorney 's question about whether we would go after attorney's fees, and that is different from actually doing it ,althoughwe reserve that right

        Arg0: an attorney 's
        Rel: question
        Arg1: about whether we would go after attorney 's fees , and that is different from actually doing it , although we reservethat right

Example: question-n: arg 0 and 2

        person: ns, tense: ns, aspect: ns, voice: ns, form: ns

        Your questions to some experts

        Arg0: Your
        Rel: questions
        Arg2: to some experts

Example: question-n: Lots of arg ms

        person: ns, tense: ns, aspect: ns, voice: ns, form: ns

        Our web question of the week

        Arg0: Our
        Argm-loc: web
        Rel: question
        Argm-tmp: of the week

Example: question-n: args 0 and 1

        person: ns, tense: ns, aspect: ns, voice: ns, form: ns

        Your question about the New York Times

        Arg0: Your
        Rel: question
        Arg1: about the New York Times

Example: questioning-n: Arg0,2

        person: ns, tense: ns, aspect: ns, voice: ns, form: ns

        Due in large part to Patrick's thoroughness, and his questioning of the plaintiff's doctors, the plaintiff was awardeddamages of only $3000.

        Arg0: his
        Rel: questioning
        Arg2: of the plaintiff's doctors

Roleset id: question.02 , out-of-the-question, Source: , vncls: , framnet:

question.02: QUESTION-N NOTES: Roleset based on eventive-nouns-00060. No corresponding verbnet class. Framed by Katie. (from question.02-n)

Aliases:

Alias	FrameNet	VerbNet
question (n.)

Roles:

Arg1-PPT: thing that is out of the question
Arg2-GOL: for whom/what

Example: question-n: Example with arg 2 (and an arg 1 that cannot be annotated because of the verb)

        renewing military aid had been considered out of the question for civilians,

        Rel: question
        Arg2: for civilians

Example: question-n: This is often what you'll see. You cannot annotate the thing that is 'out of the question' in these cases because of the intervening verb

Sometimes repairs are out of the question .

Rel: question

Roleset id: question.03 , have doubts, be dubious, Source: , vncls: , framnet:

question.03: QUESTIONABLE-J NOTES: Added by Julia based on WSJ data,question-v.01. Corresponds to VNcls interrogate-37.1.3. (from questionable.01-j) This frame file has been reframed following negotiations between Martha, Julia, Tim, Katie, and Ulf. The former .01 roleset included both'ask a question' and 'have doubts' senses, and has been split into .01 and .03 rolesets. Reframing allows 'questionable' to be aliased to only the 'have doubts' sense.

Aliases:

Alias	FrameNet	VerbNet
questionable (j.)	Suspiciousness
question (n.)
question (v.)
questioning (n.)

Roles:

Arg0-PAG: entity having doubts
Arg1-PPT: dubious thing

Example: question-v: transitive

        Many analysts question management's credibility.

        Arg0: Many analysts
        Rel: question
        Arg1: management's credibility

Example: questionable-j: arg1

        person: ns, tense: ns, aspect: ns, voice: ns, form: ns

        Prosecutors in Port St. Lucie, Fla., said the victim's identification of McIntyre as the suspect was questionable.

        Arg1: the victim's identification of McIntyre as the suspect
        Rel: quesionable

Example: questionable-j: args0, 1

        person: ns, tense: ns, aspect: ns, voice: ns, form: ns

        If the right was questionable by the legislature, the right of the legislature to question it could not be disputed;

        Arg1: the right
        Rel: questionable
        Arg0: by the legistlature